1. Professionalism
Lesson started on
time and all necessary handouts were prepared and arranged in advance.
2. Lesson
2.1 Lesson implementation
I started the
lesson by eliciting the rationale of a listening lesson. Lesson objectives were
briefly mentioned at the beginning to give students an idea of what the lesson
was going to be about. They were rephrased into simpler terms for the students
to understand. They were also provided at the end of each activity so students
could relate the activities to the objectives of the lesson.
Activities
conducted involved a warm-up activity, pre-stage, during-stage and post-stage.
During the warm-up activity, students seemed lost in the beginning but figured
out the intention of the activity as they proceeded. Not explicitly clarifying
the intention of the activity was deliberate as I wanted the students to
discover that with little or unclear instructions, different people will listen
or hear different things and perceive the information differently.
Step-by-step
instructions were provided explicitly to the students and little scaffolding
was provided. It was assumed that students had the necessary prior knowledge
since they are in Intermediate Level 6 hence; I did not see the need for
scaffolding. However, during the activity, I realized that with sufficient
scaffolding, students might have grasped the content better. Students also had
to rely a lot on my verbal instructions, which might have burdened students’ cognitive
load. Although this was a listening lesson, students should not be overwhelmed
with too much content as this may cause frustration if they cannot keep up.
There was a lot of teacher talk from providing instructions to reading the text
to the students. I felt that this could somehow be minimized. Instructions had
to be provided explicitly so there was no way of minimizing teacher’s verbal
content but in terms of the reading text, it could be shortened as the activity
was identifying main ideas so there was no need for a text of that length. I
posed many questions to elicit responses from students as well as offer
clarifications or follow-up explanations to students’ responses and queries. I
felt the task of certain comprehension checks and clarifications could be given
to the students so they are responsible for relaying the information to their
peers. This not only reduces the amount of teacher talk but also encourages
more participation from the students. I also made appropriate pauses throughout
the activities to check students’ understanding. I used a lot of hand gestures
to complement my speech and the reading text to facilitate better
comprehension. For example, I used my hands to gesture the term “swap”.
The activities
conducted encouraged co-operative learning. I organized pair work so that
students not only listened but also had the opportunity to interact with their
peers. Pairs then got together with another pair to discuss answers. During group work, I monitored students’
progress in discussion and circulated to offer help to struggling groups. There
was also evidence from the video clip that I responded to students throughout
the lesson by nodding in agreement and providing explicit feedback such as
“that’s right” and “yes”. In terms of feedback, I felt that I have provided both
instantaneous and timely feedback especially during the course of the activity.
When the students got the sequence mixed up, I provided feedback and
clarification informing students why they might have thought the sequence to be
in that order. I also provided recasts of mispronunciations. I used this form
of explicit error correction so that I do not direct the whole class’ attention
on a mispronunciation but simply repeated it in a correct way so everyone knew
what the student was saying. I did not see the need nor have the time to take
note of any feedback because it was provided promptly. What I could have done
was perhaps to ask students to take note of the feedback given. For example, if
there was a word that caused confusion, such as ‘kiosk’; I could have asked
students to write the word and the meaning in their book instead of just giving
and explaining the meaning without having students to write anything down.
There were also
times during the activity that I rephrased students’ description. This form of
feedback, although not written so that it could be dealt with later, was
immediately addressed. However, what I could have done differently was to call
on other students to clarify or perhaps guess what the speaker was trying to
convey. By putting the responsibility on the students, I am not just increasing
students’ opportunities for interaction but also enable students to engage in
peer feedback.
Overall, I felt
that in order for the activities to run smoothly and efficiently, there has to
be a certain amount of teacher talk in clarification and explanation. However,
this task or responsibility can be shared among the participants of the lesson,
including the teacher. I had put a lot of thought and planning into the lesson
activities and I felt that there was significant coherence in the activities
and that one activity successfully led the students into the next. Transition
of activities was effective and students were able to follow the flow of the
lesson. Towards the end of the lesson, the rationale and objective were
reiterated. The recapitulation of the lesson would have been better off done by
the students by having them inform what they have learnt. By doing so, I think
the learning content could have been reinforced and students are also given the
opportunities to reflect on what they have learnt.
2.2 Lesson
timing
I followed the
lesson plan and time allocation accordingly. The lesson finished on time and
all activities were carried out efficiently. Time was also maximized
effectively.
3. Content
I felt that
challenge was provided to greater ability students but this was not
successfully executed. I had prepared more challenging questions for students
of greater ability but have forgotten to execute them during the course of the
lesson. I was too involved in involving everyone as a class and making sure
equal participation that I neglected to take content differentiation into
account. As mentioned earlier, while monitoring and circulating during
students’ group work, I provided additional support to those who were
struggling. This was not done explicitly in front of the whole class, as only
certain specific students needed the extra guidance. As a result, this aspect
was not evident in the video clip.
4. Classroom
management and climate
In terms of physical
climate, students were seated in a U-shaped setting and were able to see the
teacher as well as other students. As for intellectual climate, I felt the
activities planned were sufficient to challenge students’ listening ability and
students were able to identify main idea and specific information. Throughout
the lesson, I have also posed several questions that probe students’ thinking
and required them to synthesize the information and evaluate what they have
learnt. With regards to social climate, there was a balance between pair work
and individual work so students were able not only to work co-operatively and
interactively but were also given the opportunities to work independently.
There were also many instances where I prompted students’ responses by
eliciting their opinions or ideas. This was done by opening the floor to students
who wish to volunteer and by nominating passive students to contribute. I
provided opportunities for students to speak up when they wanted to or when
they wanted to share their stories with the class. Hence, there was active participation
from the students. Lastly as for emotional climate, I think collaboratively, my
students and I have created a safe, respectful and positive environment, taking
into account the multi-cultural context with participants’ various first
languages. There was evidence of excessive amount of teacher talk. Although
this was indeed a listening lesson, I felt the amount of teacher talk could be
minimized, as mentioned previously.
5. Presence and
communication
I might have
spoken a bit slower than I should have. Although my students were from various
backgrounds, they are in Intermediate Level 6 so they would have understood me
perfectly even if I had spoken at a normal pace. The register used was
appropriate for classroom environment. I made sure I expose the students to
appropriate classroom discourse so they could make use of the input they
encounter in their classroom to interact with their peers. It was also evident
from the video clip that voice projection was loud enough, clear and
comprehensible. I also provided positive reinforcements to students such as
“good” and “very good”. I have good rapport with the students and this has made
lessons run very smoothly and effectively. However, I have also realized and
witnessed myself repeatedly uttering the tag question “isn’t it” incorrectly
and out of context. There were 11 occasions in total throughout the lesson. I
think I should kick this habit, as I do not wish to transfer this habit to the
students.
6.
Self-reflection
Overall from this
account of self-observation, I am aware of the certain aspects of the lesson
that could be improved and this has given me the opportunity to reflect on my
teaching and to further explore and evaluate various teaching methodologies in
order to execute a lesson more effectively and efficiently.